e-commerce, shopify, AI, AEO
Four Brands. One Cart. One Checkout.
Shopify's latest updates have me wondering whether brand loyalty is about to change hands.
One screenshot from Shopify's latest Edition stopped me in my tracks.
Four completely different brands. Four separate retailers. All purchased through one shopping cart in the Shop app.

And here's why I think that's such a big deal.
For years, we've been building ecommerce experiences designed to get consumers to spend more with an individual retailer.
Spend another $30 for free shipping.
Add this product to complete your routine.
People who bought this also bought that.
Join our loyalty programme and come back next month.
It's clever marketing. And it works.
But this new shopping experience flips that thinking on its head.
Instead of asking how we can get a customer to buy more from our store, it's asking how we can help a customer buy exactly what they need, regardless of which store sells it.
I think that's a pretty significant shift.
And for Kiwi retailers, it's particularly interesting.
We've always liked to think New Zealanders are fiercely brand loyal. We support local businesses, champion brands we love and happily recommend them to our mates.
And I think there's still plenty of truth in that.
But what happens when our loyalty shifts from the brands we love to the convenience we can't live without?
If I can get everything I need from one retailer, why would I bother shopping around?
Until now, shopping around has meant multiple websites, multiple carts and potentially multiple delivery fees.
But remove that friction, and suddenly the consumer has a lot more choice.
And perhaps the loyalty starts to move with them.
So, who actually gets the loyalty?
As a Kiwi now living in the USA, I've had a rather uncomfortable introduction to just how powerful convenience can be.
Amazon.
You can buy anything. And I mean ANYTHING.
It's become such a regular occurrence in our house that Archie now announces, "Our friends from the Amazon are here again."
And while part of me is slightly ashamed of how quickly I've adapted, I can see exactly why it works.
For me, it's the returns experience that wins.
If I'm choosing between two products, I'll sometimes buy both, knowing I can return whichever one I don't like.
I can drop eligible returns off while doing the supermarket shopping. No packaging, no printer, no additional trip and no cost.
I can only imagine the logistical nightmare behind that.
The freight. The handling. The processing.
But here's the clever part.
Making it easier for me to return things has actually made me more comfortable buying them.
Amazon has removed so much of the risk and effort from shopping that I don't spend nearly as much time second-guessing a purchase.
And the loyalty I've developed isn't necessarily to the brands I'm buying. Embarrassingly, my loyalty is now to Amazon.
Which brings me straight back to that Shopify screenshot.
If Shop becomes the easiest place to discover, compare and purchase products from multiple retailers, does the customer become loyal to Shop rather than the individual businesses?
And if AI becomes the personal shopper that selects those products for us, does the loyalty move again?
Consumer-first doesn't necessarily mean spending less.
This is what I find particularly fascinating.
At first glance, AI shopping sounds like it could be terrible for retailers.
A customer tells their assistant exactly what they need, sets a budget and asks it to find the best options.
No browsing through beautifully curated collections.
No getting distracted by something they didn't know they needed.
No adding another $30 worth of products to qualify for free shipping.
But my Amazon experience suggests something else might happen too.
When shopping becomes easier, and the perceived risk of getting a purchase wrong disappears, consumers may actually buy more.
So perhaps this isn't simply about consumers becoming more disciplined shoppers.
It's about the shopping experience being designed around their needs rather than the retailer's sales targets.
And the businesses that understand that distinction could be the ones that benefit most.
And Shopify isn't stopping at the shopping cart.
This is where AI starts to make things even more interesting.
Shopify has been developing the infrastructure to make products discoverable and purchasable through AI shopping experiences.
Its Universal Commerce Protocol, developed with Google, is designed to help AI agents and retailers communicate throughout the shopping journey.
And Shopify's Agentic Storefronts are helping merchants make their products available through AI-powered channels.
The important distinction is that the Shop app's multi-brand checkout and AI shopping are separate developments.
But together, they point towards a future where a customer might never need to visit your website to make a purchase.
Imagine telling your AI assistant:
"I need a new lunchbox, sunscreen for the kids and some laundry detergent. Nothing fancy, decent quality, and keep it under $100."
Your assistant compares products, checks pricing, reviews availability and helps you put together a cart.
Potentially across multiple retailers.
And you haven't opened a single website.
Now, we're not at the point where every Kiwi can do all of this seamlessly across every retailer. The technology and integrations are still developing.
But we're certainly heading in that direction.
For years, retailers have worked hard to bring customers to their websites. Now the question is whether customers will need to come at all.
What happens when price matching becomes effortless?
We've always been pretty good at hunting down a bargain in New Zealand.
But there's usually a limit to how much effort we'll put into saving a few dollars.
If the difference is $5, am I really going to open six tabs, compare delivery costs and set up another customer account?
Probably not.
But an AI assistant can compare those options in seconds.
And that's where things get uncomfortable for retailers.
The convenience that once kept a customer coming back to your store may no longer be enough.
If the same product is available elsewhere for less, with better delivery options, why wouldn't AI recommend it?
That doesn't mean every retailer needs to race to the bottom on price.
But it does mean businesses need to be much clearer about why they're worth choosing.
Maybe it's faster local delivery.
Maybe it's a better product.
Maybe it's expertise, sustainability, after-sales support or a genuinely brilliant customer experience.
Whatever it is, that value needs to be obvious.
Not just to the customer, but increasingly to the technology helping them shop.
So where does that leave Kiwi retailers?
I don't think the answer is to panic about AI or assume your website is suddenly irrelevant.
People will still want to browse. They'll still fall in love with brands. They'll still buy things because they like the story, the experience or the people behind them.
But I do think we need to reconsider what makes a customer come back.
For years, we've measured ecommerce success through website traffic, conversion rates, average order value and repeat purchases.
Those metrics still matter.
But what happens when discovery takes place through an AI assistant, the cart belongs to a shopping platform and the transaction happens somewhere other than your website?
It becomes harder to rely on the traditional levers we've used to drive sales.
And that's why I'd be looking closely at a few things.
Your product information. Accurate descriptions, pricing, availability, variants and shipping details are becoming incredibly important. AI can't confidently recommend what it can't understand.
Your point of difference. If your products are being compared alongside competitors, why should yours be chosen?
Your AI visibility. Search is changing, and ecommerce is changing with it. Being discoverable through AI-powered shopping experiences is becoming another part of the equation.
Your customer experience. Amazon has shown me that convenience can create enormous loyalty, even when the consumer has very little attachment to the individual brands they're buying.
And perhaps most importantly, your relationship with the customer.
If the shopping platform owns the checkout and AI helps make the buying decision, what are you doing to make sure the customer still remembers you?
Maybe loyalty isn't disappearing. It's just changing hands.
That's my biggest takeaway from Shopify's latest Edition.
While this new shopping experience could mean more price comparison, fewer impulse purchases and less control for retailers, it could also mean more discovery, less friction and greater confidence to purchase.
My Amazon habits are certainly proof that convenience doesn't always lead to restraint.
But they have made me think differently about loyalty.
Because while I couldn't tell you the names of half the brands arriving at my front door, I know exactly where I'll go when I need something tomorrow.
And perhaps that's the question Kiwi retailers should be asking.
Are your customers loyal to your brand, or simply to the easiest way to buy what they need?
Because if convenience is what they're loyal to, Shopify and AI are about to give them a whole lot more options.
Topics